The Bail Reform Act of 1984: A Comprehensive Analysis

The Bail Reform Act of 1984 (BRA) is a landmark piece of legislation that revolutionized the way bail is determined in the United States. Prior to the BRA, bail was often set based on the defendant's ability to pay, which led to a system that was inequitable and often resulted in the pretrial detention of poor and minority defendants. The BRA sought to address these concerns by establishing a set of factors that judges must consider when setting bail, including the defendant's risk of flight and danger to the community.

The BRA was passed in response to a series of Supreme Court decisions that had limited the government's ability to detain defendants before trial. In 1964, the Court held in Gideon v. Wainwright that states must provide legal counsel to indigent defendants in criminal cases. This decision made it more difficult to justify the pretrial detention of defendants who could not afford bail.

In 1972, the Court held in Stack v. Boyle that the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against excessive bail applies to both pretrial and post-conviction bail. This decision further limited the government's ability to detain defendants before trial.

The Bail Reform Act of 1984

by Benjamin Wittes

4.6 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	1961 KB
Print length	:	96 pages
Screen Reader	:	Supported

FREE

The BRA was passed in an effort to address the concerns raised by these Supreme Court decisions. The act sought to create a more equitable and fair system of bail that would protect the rights of defendants while also ensuring the safety of the community.

The BRA contains a number of key provisions, including:

• A requirement that judges consider the following factors when setting bail:
  • The nature and severity of the offense charged
  • The defendant's criminal history
  • The defendant's ties to the community
  • The defendant's risk of flight
  • The defendant's danger to the community
• A presumption that the defendant will be released on bail unless the government can show that one of the following factors is present:
  • The defendant is a flight risk
  • The defendant is a danger to the community
  • The defendant has committed a serious crime involving violence or the use of a weapon
• A requirement that the government provide a written statement of its reasons for seeking to detain the defendant before trial

The BRA has had a significant impact on the way bail is determined in the United States. Prior to the act, the vast majority of defendants were released on bail. However, after the BRA was passed, the number of defendants released on bail declined significantly. This decline was particularly pronounced among black and Hispanic defendants.

The BRA has also been criticized for leading to an increase in the number of defendants who are detained before trial. In 2016, the Bureau of Justice Statistics reported that nearly 450,000 defendants were held in jail before trial, a 20% increase from 2000.

The BRA has been the subject of much debate in recent years. Some critics argue that the act has led to an increase in pretrial detention and that it has made it more difficult for poor and minority defendants to obtain bail. Others argue that the act is necessary to protect the safety of the community.

The debate over the BRA is likely to continue in the years to come. As the United States continues to grapple with issues of mass incarceration and racial disparities in the criminal justice system, the BRA is likely to play a central role in the discussion.

The Bail Reform Act of 1984 is a landmark piece of legislation that has had a significant impact on the way bail is determined in the United States. The act has been both praised and criticized, and its implications for the future are still being debated. However, there is no doubt that the BRA has played a major role in shaping the American criminal justice system.

The Bail Reform Act of 1984

by Benjamin Wittes

4.6 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	1961 KB
Print length	:	96 pages
Screen Reader	:	Supported

FREE